Fics like A Crowd

Updated with new art 10/2023. Written 2016 in response to a Magic Anon on my silly RP blog that turned Jimmy into a puppet & Slappy into a homunculus, the in-universe implication being that some bastard sorcerer (cough Wally cough) was responsible.

You may also like

  1. Horror Master by Madhat886 (Worm - Fandom, My Little Pony Generation 4: Friendship is Magic (Cartoon 2010), more)
  2. First Kiss (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine)
  3. Zoo-Wee-Mama! by I_Love_Fish_An_Unhealthy_Amount (Death Note (Anime & Manga), Diary of a Wimpy Kid Series - Jeff Kinney, more)
  4. Goosebumps of Pleasure (Original Series) by FoxsFire (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine)
  5. My Hero: Horror Master by Madhat886 (僕のヒーローアカデミア | Boku no Hero Academia | My Hero Academia (Anime & Manga), My Little Pony Generation 4: Friendship is Magic (Cartoon 2010), more)
  6. (Come Undone) by coffinbreath (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine)
  7. Maddie's Wondrous Box of Scares by MusikKeyKid (Ever After High, Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine)
  8. Brooke Rodgers Is Dead by MusikKeyKid (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine)
  9. With Loathing, Love Slappy by saltearth (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine)
  10. Little Porn Shop of Horrors by specialkay0 (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine)
  11. Death Battle Ideas S9 Bonus by TheGametimer (Death Battle (Web Series), Multi-Fandom, more)
  12. Meeting Keith by Wolfgirl19 (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine, Goosebumps (Movies))
  13. Horrorland X Showtime by Vega_Valentine (プロジェクトセカイ カラフルステージ！| Project SEKAI COLORFUL STAGE! (Video Game), Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine)
  14. Spiderland by StormCity (Spider-Man - All Media Types, Spider-Man (Comicverse), more)
  15. Goosebumps: Welcome to Dark Falls by BloodAndGoosebumps (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine)
  16. Dear Janey by MusikKeyKid (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine)
  17. Goosebumps University: The Ultimate Evil by Misery_X3 (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine, Goosebumps (TV 1995))
  18. AITA: Goosebumps Edition by melonystrawberry (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine)
  19. My Ideas for ChildlikeGoblinQueen's Monster of the Week by MasterOfAwesome24 (The Owl House (Cartoon), The Mummy (Movies 1999-2008), more)
  20. A Menacing Halloween by Wolfgirl19 (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine, Goosebumps (Movies))