Fics like With Loathing, Love Slappy

Despite her best attempts at forgetting the way her dysfunction fractured family does after she vanquished him six years ago, Amy's teen years have been overshadowed by the shadow cast by Slappy. And then they meet again.

You may also like

  1. Death Battle Ideas S9 Bonus by TheGametimer (Death Battle (Web Series), Multi-Fandom, more)
  2. Goosebumps of Pleasure (Original Series) by FoxsFire (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine)
  3. Horror Master by Madhat886 (Worm - Fandom, My Little Pony Generation 4: Friendship is Magic (Cartoon 2010), more)
  4. A Crowd by coffinbreath (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine)
  5. A Chaotic Throne Of Heroes by Fbs_worlds (Fate/stay night & Related Fandoms, Fate/Grand Order, more)
  6. Zoo-Wee-Mama! by I_Love_Fish_An_Unhealthy_Amount (Death Note (Anime & Manga), Diary of a Wimpy Kid Series - Jeff Kinney, more)
  7. Reimagined Isle: A Pahkitew Island Rewrite by Wooglebear (Total Drama (Cartoon), Goosebumps (Movies), more)
  8. The Witch of Hawkins by AsMuchAsIWish (Stranger Things (TV 2016), Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine, more)
  9. My Hero: Horror Master by Madhat886 (僕のヒーローアカデミア | Boku no Hero Academia | My Hero Academia (Anime & Manga), My Little Pony Generation 4: Friendship is Magic (Cartoon 2010), more)
  10. Swimming Lessons by melonystrawberry (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine)
  11. The Black Magic of the Werewolf by Sapph1cSelene (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine, Goosebumps: Escape from Horrorland (Video Game))
  12. AITA: Goosebumps Edition by melonystrawberry (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine)
  13. Little Porn Shop of Horrors by specialkay0 (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine)
  14. Goosebumps University: The Ultimate Evil by Misery_X3 (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine, Goosebumps (TV 1995))
  15. The Silverscale Arena 25: February 2023 by Baskerra_Hellmane (Transformers - All Media Types, Wallace & Gromit, more)
  16. Let's Get Invisible! II - Don't Fear the Mirror by zipzap256 (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine)
  17. horrorland detour by randomfills (Supernatural (TV 2005), Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine)
  18. Meeting Keith by Wolfgirl19 (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine, Goosebumps (Movies))
  19. Brooke Rodgers Is Dead by MusikKeyKid (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine)
  20. The Favor by HayzieHay (Goosebumps Series - R. L. Stine, Goosebumps (Movies))