Fics like Many Happy Returns

Tony is in town a month before Riff finally gets his head out of his ass and realizes that all of Tony’s hemming and hawing regarding the Jets isn’t, like, code or anything.

You may also like

  1. Love's Labors by insertcoolname13 (West Side Story (2021), West Side Story - Bernstein/Sondheim/Laurents)
  2. I don’t own a single gun by robbersxfilms (West Side Story (2021), West Side Story - Bernstein/Sondheim/Laurents)
  3. Racetrack Higgins, the Newsie formally known as Mouthpiece. by Brooksy_May (Newsies - All Media Types, West Side Story (2021))
  4. If you were the winter, I know I'd be the snow by thembonesthembones (West Side Story (1961), West Side Story (2021))
  5. As You Shall Use Me Hereafter by orphan_account (West Side Story (2021))
  6. Until This Night by InkandPen22 (West Side Story (2021), West Side Story - Bernstein/Sondheim/Laurents)
  7. We Must Have You Dance by orphan_account (West Side Story (2021))
  8. All The World Is Only You And Me! - West Side Story by AlisonSunny (West Side Story (2021), West Side Story (1961), more)
  9. One Last Dance at the Gym by birdinblue (West Side Story - Bernstein/Sondheim/Laurents, West Side Story (2021), more)
  10. Both arms cradle you know by ShapReads987 (West Side Story (2021), West Side Story (1961))
  11. Falling Slowly by theflyingdalek (West Side Story (2021), West Side Story (1961), more)
  12. A Winter's Tale by insertcoolname13 (West Side Story (2021), West Side Story - Bernstein/Sondheim/Laurents)
  13. busted and blue by mercutibro (West Side Story (2021))
  14. you're a family man by dulce_chisme, restlesstxclimb (West Side Story (1961), West Side Story - Bernstein/Sondheim/Laurents, more)
  15. The Fallout by neontrench (West Side Story (2021), West Side Story - Bernstein/Sondheim/Laurents)
  16. Through My Eyes by thevibrantruby (West Side Story (1961), West Side Story - Bernstein/Sondheim/Laurents, more)
  17. Mike Faist Fluff Alphabet by orphan_account (West Side Story (2021), Dear Evan Hansen - Pasek & Paul/Levenson (Broadway Cast) Actor RPF, more)
  18. Baby John Sickfic by dontshootforthestarsshoothigher (West Side Story (1961), West Side Story (2021))
  19. We know what we are // But know not what we may be by user230507021118079 (West Side Story (2021))
  20. An Empty Store by McCarthaEvita (West Side Story - Bernstein/Sondheim/Laurents, West Side Story (1961), more)