Fics like I Know I Shouldn't Love You (But I Do)

Mark has a problem. Not a ship-destroying, multiverse-ending, leaves-a-permanent-mental-impact sort of problem, no. A problem that is, in the grand scheme of things, quite small. And yet this is possibly the most scared he’s ever been of something. Because at some point while traversing an untold number of universes with them, Mark kind-of-sort-of-maybe developed feelings for the Captain, and he doesn't know how to tell them, or if he even should.

You may also like

  1. Bright 'Till We're Burned by EYESORE_BOI (In Space With Markiplier (Web Series), Markiplier TV (Web Series), more)
  2. And It Starts Again by Echo_in_a_Sky (In Space With Markiplier (Web Series))
  3. The Shampoo Fic by HopePunkHaze (In Space With Markiplier (Web Series))
  4. I Don't Mind Doing it With You by Suledin_Somniari (In Space With Markiplier (Web Series))
  5. try out the gallows on your own neck by hellcat_jirel (In Space With Markiplier (Web Series))
  6. Loose Ends: Over 10.5 Billion by VampiricYoshi (In Space With Markiplier (Web Series))
  7. it’ll be fine (because it’s always been fine) by PebblePoet (In Space With Markiplier (Web Series))
  8. A Rest Long Overdue by Sterling_Starlight (In Space With Markiplier (Web Series))
  9. After Lifetimes Without You by Undeadbanjos (In Space With Markiplier (Web Series))
  10. The Pros and Cons of Unconventional Workplace Training Videos by HopePunkHaze (In Space With Markiplier (Web Series))
  11. There Was No Grass On The Sub by adenium_iron (Iron Lung (2026), Markiplier TV (Web Series), more)
  12. heavy on my mind by buc_eebarnes (In Space With Markiplier (Web Series))
  13. It's Just a Cold by ZeeBear (In Space With Markiplier (Web Series))
  14. go in as a green light by buc_eebarnes (In Space With Markiplier (Web Series))
  15. Chase Me by TheKnightMarket (In Space With Markiplier (Web Series))
  16. Simon meets the Ipliers (Alternatively: The Convict vs his fellow Markiplier egos) by DontLookDontLookDontLookDontLook (Iron Lung (2026), In Space With Markiplier (Web Series), more)
  17. under starless skies we are lost by buc_eebarnes (In Space With Markiplier (Web Series))
  18. SloeBurn by thepossumwrites (Iron Lung (2026), Project Hail Mary (2026), more)
  19. Mirror, Mirror by TheKnightMarket (Who Killed Markiplier? (Web Series), A Heist With Markiplier (Web Series), more)
  20. A Glittery Aftermath by uncrownedmonochromist (In Space With Markiplier (Web Series))