Fics like But I'm Not American?

5 times someone found out that Steve was Italian + the 1 time Steve told everyone he wasn't even American.

You may also like

1. Nice & Quiet by nobetterlove (Stranger Things (TV 2016))
2. Anywhere, Anytime by AidaRonan (Stranger Things (TV 2016))
3. sir stephen strider finds his suzie by lesbianrobin (Stranger Things (TV 2016))
4. Shovel Talks by steph_fangirl (Stranger Things (TV 2016))
5. Between the Slides by spiderbats (The Black Phone (Movies - Derrickson), Stranger Things (TV 2016))
6. Turn Your Back on Mother Nature by gr0gu (Stranger Things (TV 2016))
7. Vicious Mockery (never won a fight) by Yaoi_Bill_Nye (Stranger Things (TV 2016))
8. to ease the pressure off (my ever worried mind) by FagurFiskur (Stranger Things (TV 2016))
9. I'd Burn the Castle for You by AidaRonan (Stranger Things (TV 2016))
10. you took my heart (i was sleeping) by lameparties (Stranger Things (TV 2016))
11. You can put it all on me, you can laugh and you can bleed by steveharringtoned (Stranger Things (TV 2016))
12. When There's Still So Many Things To Say Unsaid by BlackUnicorn (Stranger Things (TV 2016))
13. Lapse by Yikes_Writes (Stranger Things (TV 2016))
14. Rewind, Relive, and Rebound by LittleGreenGremlin (Stranger Things (TV 2016), The Black Phone (2022), more)
15. smoking guns (hot to the touch) by fivecenturiesverse (Stranger Things (TV 2016))
16. Now It´s Your Turn, Baby by datfangirlman (Stranger Things (TV 2016))
17. Father's Day (The World's Greatest Babysitter) by mummifiedgoose (Stranger Things (TV 2016))
18. Guitar Romantic Search Adventure by outofmygourd (Stranger Things (TV 2016))
19. what love is by kissesforcas (Stranger Things (TV 2016))
20. a cinematic vision ensued (like the holiest dream) by fivecenturiesverse (Stranger Things (TV 2016))