Fics like When One Door Closes

Set across two timelines. Toni and Shelby meet during their senior year of college, intense feelings and jealousy make them strangers again. What happens when Shelby turns up in the middle of the night to Toni and Regan's apartment 2 years later?

You may also like

1. Ditto Bitch, Different Her by EmilyWritesStuff (The Wilds (TV 2020))
2. You're Not Some F*cking Bear Grylls Character, Leah Rilke by EmilyWritesStuff (The Wilds (TV 2020))
3. if there's a god in heaven (you can show me) by breezered (The Wilds (TV 2020))
4. The Tumblr Prompts Series by EmilyWritesStuff (The Wilds (TV 2020))
5. Curtain Call by bakerloo (The Wilds (TV 2020))
6. The 12-Step Program (The Wilds (TV 2020))
7. blue sky mind by thejunebugg (The Wilds (TV 2020))
8. Hoops, I did it again by shnedarek (The Wilds (TV 2020))
9. be my someday by tnr92 (The Wilds (TV 2020))
10. It's Complicated by orphan_account (The Wilds (TV 2020))
11. I Hate Accidents (Except When We Went From Friends To This) by orphan_account (The Wilds (TV 2020))
12. there's something in the static (i think i've been having revelations) by explosivesky (The Wilds (TV 2020))
13. see through to the kitchen by overnights (The Wilds (TV 2020))
14. Who's gonna love you (if it ain't me) by Darklord_discourse (The Wilds (TV 2020))
15. Is this the final stop? by DontWasteYourEmotion (The Wilds (TV 2020))
16. Old Flame by twop69 (The Wilds (TV 2020))
17. I'll do what he never did... I promise by DevotedDisaster (The Wilds (TV 2020))
18. she's my religion by clarkedarling (The Wilds (TV 2020))
19. all of you, all of me, intertwined by fleamonttpotter (The Wilds (TV 2020))
20. Dear Reader... by badmeanburner (The Wilds (TV 2020))