Fics like Old Flame

Ten years after Shelby unceremoniously broke Toni's heart and vanished from her life, a twist of fate brings them back together when Toni rescues her from a dangerous fire. Toni swears she's moved on and doesn't want to have anything to do with Shelby again, but her heart seems to have missed the memo.

You may also like

1. i'll come around if you ask me by shalifoemood (The Wilds (TV 2020))
2. say it out loud (i see right past you) by tnr92 (The Wilds (TV 2020))
3. if there's a god in heaven (you can show me) by breezered (The Wilds (TV 2020))
4. i'd follow you anywhere by uselace (The Wilds (TV 2020), Women's Basketball RPF)
5. all we've got is each other by JourEtNuit (The Wilds (TV 2020))
6. The Tumblr Prompts Series by EmilyWritesStuff (The Wilds (TV 2020))
7. Handle My Heart (Nobody has to know) by HeavensIdentity (The Wilds (TV 2020))
8. how about an icebreaker? by tnr92 (The Wilds (TV 2020))
9. You've Got Time by CordialFresh (The Wilds (TV 2020))
10. You're Not Some F*cking Bear Grylls Character, Leah Rilke by EmilyWritesStuff (The Wilds (TV 2020))
11. we made quite a mess, babe by nrhw77 (The Wilds (TV 2020))
12. Just One Night by Mlssl (The 100 (TV), The Wilds (TV 2020), more)
13. be my someday by tnr92 (The Wilds (TV 2020))
14. The Old Switcharoo by tnr92 (The Wilds (TV 2020))
15. The 12-Step Program (The Wilds (TV 2020))
16. Remember When? by Anonymous2020 (The Wilds (TV 2020))
17. Ditto Bitch, Different Her by EmilyWritesStuff (The Wilds (TV 2020))
18. i never knew (i could feel that much) by TheGoatWithAPen (The Wilds (TV 2020))
19. enjoy your youth (sounds like a threat) by girlbossgretchen (The Wilds (TV 2020), New Girl (TV 2011))
20. blue sky mind by thejunebugg (The Wilds (TV 2020))