Fics like Perfect.

Eli just thinks Klitz is perfect.

You may also like

1. Almost Getting Caught by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
2. The Closet Has a Sliding Glass Door by Milk_and_Egg (The Girl Next Door (2004))
3. over my cold dead body by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
4. Seven Minutes by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
5. He's got love to give by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004), danonation - Fandom)
6. cold hands by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
7. why not by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
8. yes homo by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
9. This Not Thing Thing by urlkelley (The Girl Next Door (2004))
10. Camboy by urlkelley (The Girl Next Door (2004))
11. Spilled Coke by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
12. Son of Sam by neilpissyrega (The Girl Next Door (2004))
13. silly gay boys by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
14. boys on film by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
15. Grim Grinning Ghosts by always_andromeda (The Girl Next Door (2004))
16. no homo (said like a liar) by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
17. Shits & Giggles by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
18. Distraction by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
19. Homework Help by theuglierthebetter (The Girl Next Door (2004))
20. Paul Dano Cinematic Universe One-shots by starlight_searches (The Batman (Movie 2022), The Girl Next Door (2004), more)