Fics like why not

eli decides he wants to get his lip pierced. klitz and eli gay?

You may also like

  1. The Closet Has a Sliding Glass Door by Milk_and_Egg (The Girl Next Door (2004))
  2. This Not Thing Thing by urlkelley (The Girl Next Door (2004))
  3. Paul Dano Cinematic Universe One-shots by starlight_searches (The Batman (Movie 2022), The Girl Next Door (2004), more)
  4. Total Eklitz of the Heart by VampireVince (The Girl Next Door (2004))
  5. Distraction by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
  6. Then Beg For It by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
  7. silly gay boys by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
  8. i try to listen to your words but i can't feel my head and it's unraveling by the_rorster (The Girl Next Door (2004))
  9. Camboy pt. 2 by urlkelley (The Girl Next Door (2004))
  10. cold hands by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
  11. Valentine Chocolate Box Collection by always_andromeda (For Ellen (2012), War and Peace (TV 2016), more)
  12. Kiss Me by SunBeem (The Girl Next Door (2004))
  13. The Perfect Disaster of a First Date by Milk_and_Egg (The Girl Next Door (2004))
  14. over my cold dead body by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
  15. Grim Grinning Ghosts by always_andromeda (The Girl Next Door (2004))
  16. Riddler: Into The Dano-Verse (The Batman (Movie 2022), Little Miss Sunshine (2006), more)
  17. Strange Trails Collection (500 Follower Milestone Tumblr Event) by always_andromeda (War and Peace (TV 2016), Stranger Things (TV 2016), more)
  18. pictureinme/moodforaday's kinktober 2023 by moodforaday (Breakfast on Pluto (2005), Red Eye (2005), more)
  19. There’s nothing gay about helping your friend out by cannabissalad (The Girl Next Door (2004))
  20. 16 bits of dodgy tension by burn456 (The Girl Next Door (2004))