Fics like Eat Your Heart Out, Tom Selleck

Jack is four. For real, now, and everything is great. Cas is doin' awesome at the dad stuff, Sam has fully leaned into the awkward uncle Dean always knew he had lurking inside him, and Dean is... uh. Doing fine too. Trying to do right by Jack, keeping his people happy, all that good stuff. He's also in love with Cas, which, y'know. He's dealing with. So. But an encounter at the diner one day screws everything up, and in the aftermath, the carefully constructed balancing act they've been maintaining falls apart. And worst of all, this doesn't just make things hard with Cas— it threatens Dean's relationship with Jack, too. Well, hey. At least it's not another apocalypse?

You may also like

1. because he wears cowboy boots by mmtion (Supernatural)
2. Kinda Like Family, Kinda Like Love by followyourenergy (Supernatural)
3. The Golden Apples of the Sun by intothesilentland (Supernatural)
4. The Handyman's Special by Carrieosity (Supernatural)
5. what's missing is found (our souls can exhale now) by sobsicles (Supernatural)
6. Because it is by 60r3d0m (Supernatural)
7. You and Your Husband by 1astofthereal1s (Supernatural)
8. You Called It Love, I Called It Torture by GalaxyThreads, SpiritClusters (Supernatural)
9. hope, love, glory by showedupatyourparty (Supernatural)
10. Eye of the Needle by cenotaphy (Supernatural)
11. Autrement, Danger - or, The Account of an Exceedingly Long Day by awed_frog (Supernatural)
12. To Change the Things We Can by cenotaphy (Supernatural)
13. Cryptic Soulmark by Inkblooded_Witch, Psynatural (Supernatural)
14. right where you left me by Nepenthene (Supernatural)
15. thunder road by dothraki_shieldmaiden (Supernatural)
16. Happily Ever After by Castielslostwings (Supernatural)
17. Questionable Methods (Sam Snaps) by FelOllie (Supernatural)
18. Mr. Blue Sky by anyrei, queerwolf79 (Supernatural)
19. Mellow is the Man by marquiavellian (Supernatural (TV 2005), Supernatural)
20. love bade me welcome by mmtion (Supernatural)