Fics like Not for The Masses, Only for You

There's a new priest in town, and you're not sure what to think of him - until you realize your feelings for him. (will be updated once in a while despite being set to 'completed')

You may also like

1. Lead Us Not Into Temptation by orphan_account (Midnight Mass (TV))
2. one day when i was lost he died upon that cross by elithewho (Midnight Mass (TV))
3. thy kingdom come by nighimpossible (Midnight Mass (TV))
4. sacramentum by pondslime (Midnight Mass (TV))
5. heart-shaped box by cakecakecake (Midnight Mass (TV))
6. Parent/Teacher Night by formerly_drabbletastic (Midnight Mass (TV))
7. confessions and benders by seemeinacrown (Midnight Mass (TV))
8. Through the Darkness by mareyshelley (Midnight Mass (TV))
9. Confess Your Sins by DominantPomegranate (Midnight Mass (TV))
10. Carnal Desires by localmothman (Midnight Mass (TV))
11. sacraments by Theobule (Midnight Mass (TV))
12. baby, you need to leave (cause I'm getting drunk on your noble deeds) by scorpiod (Midnight Mass (TV))
13. Sinning And Winning by TheMultitudesOfMe (Midnight Mass (TV), The Midnight Club (TV))
14. show me how to save my soul by whiteshipnightjar (Midnight Mass (TV))
15. Cherry Picking by NoseBridgePinch (Stranger Things (TV 2016), Midnight Mass (TV))
16. I Feel Evil Creeping In by Kasiarzyna (Midnight Mass (TV))
17. The Night Father Paul Went Shopping for Slim Fit Jeans by PlainLo_inthemorning (Midnight Mass (TV))
18. Just Another Movie Night by orphan_account (Midnight Mass (TV))
19. The Night Father Paul Let You Sit on His Lap by PlainLo_inthemorning (Midnight Mass (TV))
20. Romans 12:1 (Midnight Mass (TV))