Fics like Starry Night (Mothman/Reader)

A late-night stargazing opportunity turns into an unlikely meeting- and cuddles- with a cryptid

You may also like

  1. mothman is real and he wants to kill me by wesslan (Batman - All Media Types, Mothman (Folklore))
  2. Love at first sighting by EyelessJackLover35 (Mothman (Folklore))
  3. you come in here, you drink my coffee (Mothman (Folklore), Original Work)
  4. Feathers & Fidelity by finchieclown (Mothman (Folklore))
  5. There is a Light by MothmanIzReal (Mothman (Folklore), Buzzfeed Unsolved (Web Series))
  6. The Main Reason To Visit West Virginia Is Not, In Fact, The Scenery by Corvid_Knight (Homestuck, Mothman (Folklore))
  7. Love Bug by orphan_account (Original Work, Mothman (Folklore))
  8. Softer Than the Summer Night by GoblinofLichens (Mothman (Folklore))
  9. Visiting Town by ScalesForever (Good Omens (TV), Good Omens - Neil Gaiman & Terry Pratchett, more)
  10. Irresistible Glow by BeebThatScreams (Batman - All Media Types, Mothman (Folklore))
  11. Petting The Mothman That Lives in Your Attic by Syntax (Monster Girls | Monster Boys, Mothman (Folklore))
  12. Light Trap by CUMMANDER%20OSHA (Mothman (Folklore))
  13. Liminal Time by EnemyArtichoke (呪術廻戦 | Jujutsu Kaisen (Manga), 呪術廻戦 | Jujutsu Kaisen (Anime), more)
  14. A Quiet Night in West Virginia by Greater_Axelord (Mothman (Folklore))
  15. My Light by Anomaly_Hivemind (Mothman (Folklore))
  16. The Nice and Accurate Mothman Prophecies by Tired_Lazarus, scullyphile (Good Omens - All Media Types, Good Omens (TV), more)
  17. Harvest Festival by sootnose (Original Work, Finnish Mythology, more)
  18. Dr. Appleseed's Etiquette Almanac of the Supernatural and Paranormal by TheStoryEnthusiast (Cryptids - Fandom, Mothman (Folklore), more)
  19. My.... Mothman?!?!?!1!?1 by pastaflavouredjuulpod (Mothman (Folklore))
  20. i, ebony dark'ness dementia raven way, become The Most Goffic :) by orphan_account (Mothman (Folklore))