Fics like Petting The Mothman That Lives in Your Attic

yup.

You may also like

1. Voluntary Sacrifice by MoonshineNightlight (Terato - Fandom, Original Work, more)
2. The Demon King of the Desert by Oreana (Original Work, exophilia - Fandom, more)
3. The Main Reason To Visit West Virginia Is Not, In Fact, The Scenery by Corvid_Knight (Homestuck, Mothman (Folklore))
4. Taylor Hebert-Fateburn the First, Monster Lord of Brockton Bay by GeneralPatton1000 (Parahumans Series - Wildbow, Monster Girl Quest, more)
5. The Witch's Lair: An 'Escape or Rape' Choose Your Own Adventure by frunner (Original Work, Monster Girls | Monster Boys)
6. Between Sun and Sand by mugen91 (Monster Girl Encyclopedia, Original Work, more)
7. The Author's Thinly Veiled Fetishes: The Smuttening (Monster Girls | Monster Boys, Monster Girl Encyclopedia, more)
8. mothman is real and he wants to kill me by wesslan (Batman - All Media Types, Mothman (Folklore))
9. Mothman for U.S. Senate: An Indescribable Horror You Can Trust by eddiebloom3 (Political RPF - US 21st c., Mothman (Folklore))
10. Monster Girl Encyclopedia Encounter Compendium by Alleskeins (Monster Girl Encyclopedia, Monster Girls | Monster Boys)
11. Courtship Confusion by MoonshineNightlight (Original Work, Terato - Fandom, more)
12. mirror by darkchylde (Monster Girls | Monster Boys, Original Work)
13. The Unusual Circumstances of Monster Girls by AstreaExia (モンスター娘のいる日常 | Monster Musume no Iru Nichijou, Monster Girl Encyclopedia, more)
14. If I Could Touch You by Abyss_Slut (Original Work, Monster Girls | Monster Boys)
15. Hooves in the Snow by Demureck, S0U1, TheZeratul (Monster Girls | Monster Boys, Monster Girl Encyclopedia)
16. To Speak Without Words by Oreana (exophilia - Fandom, teratophilia - Fandom, more)
17. Dance of the Nymphs by badbreadpuns (Original Work, Monster Girls | Monster Boys)
18. Equine Entanglement by SmuttyBoy (Original Work, Monster Girls | Monster Boys)
19. Grash's Plan by mugen91 (Original Work, Monster Girls | Monster Boys)
20. Midoriya Izumi's Monster Girl Farm by Digilich (僕のヒーローアカデミア | Boku no Hero Academia | My Hero Academia (Anime & Manga), モンスター娘のいる日常 | Monster Musume no Iru Nichijou, more)