Fics like the luckiest man in manhattan

"How did it stack up against all the ways you’ve been dreaming of?” Max can feel himself blushing, and oh god, she really can get him from zero to a hundred in about four seconds. “My dreams were strictly PG-13,” he deadpans. “Walks on the beach, sharing ice cream, holding hands at the movies. I seem to remember it was you who said in your message that you’d been fantasizing."

You may also like

  1. Bringer of Light by nn0405 (New Amsterdam (TV 2018))
  2. the end we start from by equifinal (New Amsterdam (TV 2018))
  3. As We Journey Round This Sun Together by Dreams_of_Spring (New Amsterdam (TV 2018))
  4. Incoming by EnidEarthling (New Amsterdam (TV 2018))
  5. you’re the only one that i want (want to be around) by leeinthesky (New Amsterdam (TV 2018))
  6. Lovers Discovered by PureShores (New Amsterdam (TV 2018))
  7. The Seven Secrets to Successful Gardening by DystonicPhonic94 (New Amsterdam (TV 2018))
  8. Of Past Regrets and New Beginnings by nn0405 (New Amsterdam (TV 2018))
  9. and ill be there when you need me: part ii by orphan_account (New Amsterdam (TV 2018))
  10. reaching in the dark by equifinal (New Amsterdam (TV 2018))
  11. our moon and star by portersbloom (New Amsterdam (TV 2018))
  12. Saving Grace by ShippersAnonymous (New Amsterdam (TV 2018), Sharpwin)
  13. roll the dice (and swear your love’s for me) by followinyourafterglow (New Amsterdam (TV 2018))
  14. Unplanned (but so so loved) by wherethelezzosgo (New Amsterdam (TV 2018))
  15. New Beginning by AnyaRazack (New Amsterdam (TV 2018))
  16. never choose between two (but i just wanted you) by leeinthesky (New Amsterdam (TV 2018))
  17. Stuck by HMG75 (New Amsterdam (TV 2018))
  18. What happiness looks like by PinkMango99 (New Amsterdam (TV 2018))
  19. London Christmas by portersbloom (New Amsterdam (TV 2018))
  20. it's what you thought that you wanted (it's still a surprise) by leeinthesky (New Amsterdam (TV 2018))