Fics like Phantasmagorical

Let's see. Benny is new in town and Ethan is drawn to him. Whether it's due to lust or magical destinies is what he wants to know.

You may also like

1. This is the Only Level by Calacious (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
2. Why did I write a MBAV chat fic in 2021 by Frog_that_writes (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
3. Soul Thread by KuroNekoFe (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
4. Nothing Like The Supernatural To Put Us Back Together by ahale (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
5. a hundred things i can't believe by halfwheeze (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
6. My Heart Will Flutter Back Into It's Cage by ThirdBoyWonder (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
7. Fun Sexy Times by MarsInsane (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
8. why do theatre kids go wild at highschool parties by orphan_account (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
9. The Date To End All Dates (Part Three) by Xx_Self_Anointed_Trash_xX (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
10. Split by 9LWrites (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
11. can i trust in you? (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
12. mary's song (oh my my my) (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
13. Savior Pulled From an Open Mouth by quinniexx1 (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
14. Evil!Benny strikes again? by MarsInsane (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
15. and if you say this makes you happy then im not the only one lying by currentshitboy (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
16. Middleton Vacation by Literally_No_One_Cares (My Babysitter's A Vampire, Good Witch (TV))
17. widest smile, kindest eyes by halfwheeze (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
18. Body Language by csi_sanders1129 (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
19. knowing your place by halfwheeze (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
20. 4 Times Benny and Ethan were Discovered to be Dating and 1 Time it was Intentional by orphan_account (My Babysitter's A Vampire)