Fics like Evil!Benny strikes again?

Fellas, is it gay if you tie your best friend to a bed and start making out with him? Evil!Benny fic.

You may also like

  1. Have a Little Confidence by MarsInsane (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  2. Spellbound: The Curse of the Lucifractor by Dxlilith (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  3. what is already yours by halfwheeze (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  4. mary's song (oh my my my) (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  5. Split by 9LWrites (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  6. Body Language by csi_sanders1129 (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  7. Canoodling by CosmicCrossing (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  8. Half moon necklaces and a sweet smoke kiss by Yui_Kuromori (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  9. if home were a boy, he'd have hands like yours by halfwheeze (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  10. friends don't love me like you by orphan_account (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  11. Right, Round, Round, Round by mrsvc (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  12. Middleton Vacation by Literally_No_One_Cares (My Babysitter's A Vampire, Good Witch (TV))
  13. That Old Black Magic by csi_sanders1129 (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  14. can i trust in you? (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  15. My Heart Will Flutter Back Into It's Cage by ThirdBoyWonder (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  16. The G's visit Whitechapel by orphan_account (My Babysitter's A Vampire, Radio Rebel (2012))
  17. Boys and Ghouls by orphan_account (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  18. Why did I write a MBAV chat fic in 2021 by Frog_that_writes (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  19. Want me by Darealestethan (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  20. Nothing Like The Supernatural To Put Us Back Together by ahale (My Babysitter's A Vampire)