Fics like Catfish - Dark Andy Barber

You’re in your final year as a college student, and you’ve been in a long-distance relationship with a man named Jacob for a few months before finding out Jacob is actually a catfish using his Dad’s photos. Distraught and a couple of days later, you’re surprised by a knock on your door late at night during a snowstorm, by none other than Jacob’s father. A few hours and a few drinks later of being snowed in, you soon realize that his intentions when coming to your house that night were far more sinister than you believed.

You may also like

  1. The (wifey) "secretary" by Bellsnuit (Defending Jacob (TV 2020))
  2. Dark Fic's by Ashley_Winchester_77 (The Avengers (Marvel Movies), Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, more)
  3. A Place Like This by theimaginesyouneveraskedfor (Defending Jacob (TV 2020))
  4. Love On The Brain by orphan_account (The Avengers (Marvel Movies), The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019), more)
  5. Finding You by buckyownsmylife (Marvel Cinematic Universe, Defending Jacob (TV 2020), more)
  6. Tumblr Ficlet Collection by grimeysociety (Marvel Cinematic Universe, Thor (Movies), more)
  7. Drabbles and Headcanons by gotnofucks (Marvel Cinematic Universe, The Avengers (Marvel Movies), more)
  8. something wicked by grimeysociety (Marvel Cinematic Universe, Thor (Movies), more)
  9. Good little wife by donutloverxo (Defending Jacob (TV 2020))
  10. We’re The Losers…And We Always Will Be by Antisociallilbrat (IT - Stephen King, IT (Movies - Muschietti), more)
  11. Dark Drabble Request 2021 by theimaginesyouneveraskedfor (The Devil All the Time (2020), Marvel Cinematic Universe, more)
  12. The Devils Den by goldenthena (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019), Fresh (2022), more)
  13. a decent man by witch_of_the_sea (Defending Jacob (TV 2020))
  14. Sloth's Monstrous Kinktober 2021 by SlothSpaghetti (Marvel, MCU, more)
  15. Return to Sender by BoxofBones (Defending Jacob (TV 2020), The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019))
  16. Summer Nights by theimaginesyouneveraskedfor (Defending Jacob (TV 2020))
  17. Loving Jacob by avantgarde4 (I Am Not Okay with This (TV 2020), Defending Jacob (TV 2020))
  18. a good neighbor by witch_of_the_sea (Defending Jacob (TV 2020))
  19. giving your body and soul to the warlocks by witch_of_the_sea (Defending Jacob (TV 2020), The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019), more)
  20. Pretty Petals by theimaginesyouneveraskedfor (Marvel Cinematic Universe, Captain America (Movies), more)