Fics like Return to Sender

Andy Barber promised he would never let you go, and come hell or high water, he’s going to keep that promise.

You may also like

1. Dark Fic's by Ashley_Winchester_77 (The Avengers (Marvel Movies), Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, more)
2. Unexpected Future by Bellsnuit (Defending Jacob (TV 2020), The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019))
3. Kinktober 2023 by myfictionaldreams (Marvel Cinematic Universe, The Avengers (Marvel Movies), more)
4. always keep my heart safe by witch_of_the_sea (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019))
5. trucker king by witch_of_the_sea (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019))
6. THE PRINCESS' SEVEN MERCENARIES | CEVANS!VARIOUS X READER by kquil (The Avengers (Marvel Movies), The Gray Man (2022), more)
7. Dirty and fluffy drabbles by donutloverxo (Marvel Cinematic Universe, The Avengers (Marvel Movies), more)
8. The First Date by paperweight91 (Knives Out (Movies), The Gray Man (2022), more)
9. sugar & spice by thyme_in_a_bubble (Marvel, Marvel Cinematic Universe, more)
10. Love On The Brain by orphan_account (The Avengers (Marvel Movies), The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019), more)
11. The (wifey) "secretary" by Bellsnuit (Defending Jacob (TV 2020))
12. New Hire by BoxofBones (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019))
13. Flamingo King by onsunnyside (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019))
14. Dreamy by onsunnyside (Defending Jacob (TV 2020))
15. Reflection by BoxofBones (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019))
16. we'll be able to fly, don't fear the reaper by grimeysociety (Marvel Cinematic Universe, Thor (Movies), more)
17. Guns, Lies & Fairy Tales by RustyTricycle (Chris Evans - Fandom, Sebastian Stan - Fandom, more)
18. Good little wife by donutloverxo (Defending Jacob (TV 2020))
19. The Power Of Your Love (is changing me) by riricitaa (Marvel Cinematic Universe, Captain America (Movies), more)
20. bite me, baby by witch_of_the_sea (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019))