Fics like Don't Throw Me Overboard, Baby

Sam's life takes a turn for the soul-crushingest worst when he finally gets what he wants-- Dean. Dean comes to him in the middle of the night after becoming human again, but pretends nothing happened during the day. He still goes home with girls at the bar, and he gets this strange look in his eyes that tears Sam apart. Broken up and broken down, Sam gets with a guy at the bar, and it all comes crumbling down at once. Sam's afraid of what they'll become after this. (I suck at writing descriptions-- it starts out angsty but ends very sexily)

You may also like

1. Some Kind of Strange Magic by lustmordred (Supernatural)
2. Pretty Little Thing by Miss_Lv (Supernatural)
3. That Sweet Memory Lingers by run%20run%20whithertits (Supernatural)
4. Hush by leonidaslion (Supernatural)
5. And the Truth Shall Set You Free by Nutkin (Supernatural)
6. Sam Winchester and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day by leonidaslion (Supernatural)
7. Our forever starts today by fallingintodivinity (Supernatural)
8. Summer Film Festival of Death by OldToadWoman (Supernatural)
9. The Inevitable by Miss_Lv (Supernatural)
10. Pulling at Threads by orphan_account (Supernatural)
11. The Psychology of Genetic Sexual Attraction by sonofabiscuit77 (Supernatural)
12. Crown and Anchor Me (or let me sail away) by Sena (Supernatural)
13. Shenanigans by dreamlittleyo, leonidaslion (Supernatural)
14. nothing was the same by orphan_account (Supernatural)
15. Skin Like Fear by orphan_account (Supernatural)
16. What You Need by BewareTheIdes15 (Supernatural)
17. Chemical High by themegalosaurus (Supernatural)
18. Top This by leonidaslion (Supernatural)
19. at the edge of the world by jejunestars (Supernatural)
20. Contagious by themegalosaurus (Supernatural)