Fics like Pretty Little Thing

Teenager Dean goes to a Halloween party for some fun, he spots a pretty little thing and chases her all evening, flirting, and eventually cornering her. Once his got his hands on her though he realizes she is actually a he, but he's fine with that. Sam snuck out after Dean just because he could, he picked a costume he knew Dean would never recognize him in. After spending the evening being chased by his brother Sam ends up in a semi public place with Dean all over him. Sam's stupid crush on his own brother is not helping matters either.

You may also like

1. Couples Counseling by MsImpala67 (Supernatural)
2. The Psychology of Genetic Sexual Attraction by sonofabiscuit77 (Supernatural)
3. Our forever starts today by fallingintodivinity (Supernatural)
4. This Story has a Happy Ending by xylodemon (Supernatural)
5. On Your Guard by theproblematique (Supernatural)
6. My Eyes Are An Ocean by entanglednow (Supernatural)
7. Ergative/Absolutive by glassedplanets (Supernatural)
8. That Sweet Memory Lingers by run%20run%20whithertits (Supernatural)
9. Excite by perpetuallycaffeinated (Supernatural)
10. In this Sunrise by hellhoundsprey (Supernatural)
11. The Three Body Problem by kisahawklin (Supernatural)
12. Top This by leonidaslion (Supernatural)
13. Shenanigans by dreamlittleyo, leonidaslion (Supernatural)
14. Sacrifice by Miss_Lv (Supernatural)
15. Inevitable Homoeroticism in Spanish Romantic Heroes by prosopopeya (Supernatural)
16. The Stray by saltandbyrne (Supernatural)
17. Hypothetically by StarlightDragon (Supernatural)
18. Supersize Me, Sammy by awabubbles (Supernatural)
19. Sure Got a Dirty Mouth by JustineDelarge (Supernatural)
20. Hush by leonidaslion (Supernatural)