Fics like Until The Masquerade Is Over

Human/College!AU: Castiel isn’t the kind of guy who would let just anyone get into his pants. He has rules to keep his dignity and not to get his heart broken by a random stranger, but when he attends a Halloween party at his college and catches the attention of a mysterious guy in a Batman suit with the most stunning, green eyes ever, Castiel finds himself breaking that rule. But who is this green-eyed man, whom he ends up having the best sex of his life with, and will Castiel ever find out who the guy behind the mask really is?

You may also like

1. Put up your Dukes by saltyfeathers (Supernatural)
2. Convenient Husbands by Annie%20D (Supernatural)
3. things happen (they do, they do, and they do) by sobsicles (Supernatural)
4. IPAMIS OL OLPRIT by emmbrancsxx0 (Supernatural)
5. Seek to Know You Better by ahurston (Supernatural)
6. That Shipwreck of Your Heart by Faster_Than_the_Speed_of_Sound (Supernatural)
7. Under The Midnight Sun by NorthernSparrow (Supernatural)
8. Strandlines by aeli_kindara (Supernatural)
9. profoundly bonded (by law) by sobsicles (Supernatural)
10. let's take a drive by sobsicles (Supernatural)
11. dumbassery, denial, doing (the three d's to the destination) by sobsicles (Supernatural)
12. Red Right Hand by Duckyboos (Supernatural)
13. The Story of You and Me by the_diggler (Supernatural)
14. canticles by 2street2car (Supernatural)
15. A Room Of One's Own by NorthernSparrow (Supernatural)
16. Number 1 Crush by Duckyboos (Supernatural)
17. oh sooner or later it all comes down to faith by sobsicles (Supernatural)
18. Angel Baby by VioletHyena (Supernatural)
19. The Graveyard Shift by PurgatoryJar, riseofthefallenone (Supernatural)
20. Grown-Ups Making Grown-Up Choices by Carrieosity (Supernatural)