Fics like Number 1 Crush

Dean, Benny, Charlie, Garth, and Cas are old college buddies. In their thirties now, they meet up once a year to shed their adult responsibilities for a week. This year it's Garth's turn to choose where they go and he's still as obsessed with horror and weird shit as he was back in college. He ends up picking a supposedly deserted hotel in the friggin' mountains. The place is creepy as hell and as night falls, two things become increasingly apparent. One: the place isn’t as deserted as they first thought, and two: Dean’s college stalker is back from the dead.

You may also like

1. The Retraining of Dean Winchester by deanwithwings (Supernatural)
2. California Waiting by ballsdeepinwinchesters (Supernatural)
3. Plot Holes by saltyfeathers (Supernatural)
4. Little Motels by orphan_account (Supernatural)
5. Be Loud, Be Brave by herbivoredinosaur (Supernatural)
6. Better than Revenge by Castielslostwings (Supernatural)
7. The Sawdust Men by linoresearch (Supernatural)
8. All about Control by Winglesss (Supernatural)
9. Three Things by PaperAnn (Supernatural)
10. The Least Bad Option by thestoryinsideme (Supernatural)
11. Inevitable Homoeroticism in Spanish Romantic Heroes by prosopopeya (Supernatural)
12. Lock, Stock & Two Smokin' Winchesters by Duckyboos (Supernatural)
13. Thunder & Angels by pm_lo (Supernatural)
14. The Life After the Morning After by saltyfeathers (Supernatural)
15. Hide and Seek by orphan_account (Supernatural)
16. Ergative/Absolutive by glassedplanets (Supernatural)
17. Never Have I Ever by sweetdean (Supernatural)
18. Captured by RedheadedSuperhero (Supernatural)
19. Gravity vs Velocity by PaperAnn (Supernatural)
20. Funny Peculiar by sysrae (Supernatural)