Fics like Cherry on Top

Toni and Cheryl get a new toy. Toni straps up and they try it out.

You may also like

1. i just want you to know who i am by cheryltonis (Riverdale (TV 2017))
2. She Didn't Know It Then by ToriWritesStories (Riverdale (TV 2017))
3. Comethru by Cherry_Poison (Riverdale (TV 2017))
4. (my youth ain't) tangled up in bad decisions by singsongsung (Riverdale (TV 2017))
5. Method Acting - Going Method For ... by drchemist (Real Person Fiction, Riverdale (TV 2017) RPF, more)
6. Straight Girls Get Married on Facebook All the Time by Alsike (Riverdale (TV 2017))
7. Best Night Ever by CrashHale (Riverdale (TV 2017))
8. Strangers by orphan_account (Riverdale (TV 2017), Archie Comics, more)
9. The Boy on the Bike by SereneCalamity (Riverdale (TV 2017), Archie Comics, more)
10. The Mixing of Sides by CrashHale (Riverdale (TV 2017))
11. Tremble by reignofthefandoms (Riverdale (TV 2017), Riverdale (TV 2017) RPF)
12. ache for you by OpportunisticHag (Riverdale (TV 2017))
13. bring the sin by orphan_account (Riverdale (TV 2017))
14. Whispers of my soul | CHONI | by RainAndThunderstorms (Riverdale (TV 2017))
15. for all i know of you now by cherylbombshells (Riverdale (TV 2017))
16. Shameless: A Normal Gallagher...Kind of by Choejhulkp9 (Shameless (US), Euphoria (TV 2019), more)
17. Scuff by WhoLenny (Riverdale (TV 2017))
18. this is the last time, I'll say a million more times by underneaththewalnuttree (Riverdale (TV 2017))
19. Bailey's Comet by geritis (Riverdale (TV 2017))
20. Fangs Doesn't Know by midlunch (Riverdale (TV 2017))