Fics like Best Night Ever

Jughead asks for a very special birthday present from Betty - for her to seduce and sleep with his best friend.

You may also like

1. Baby Sister by RiverdaleHales (Riverdale (TV 2017))
2. Scars by IndianSummer13 (Riverdale (TV 2017))
3. Do You Believe in Fate? by Jennimisk (Riverdale - Fandom, Archie Comics, more)
4. Wicked by AdamantEve (Riverdale (TV 2017))
5. five endings jughead never wrote (and one he did) by loveleee (Riverdale (TV 2017))
6. Jellybean's babysitter by PopsAfterDark (Riverdale (TV 2017), Archie Comics)
7. The Mixing of Sides by CrashHale (Riverdale (TV 2017))
8. One Week by Aud_Diane (Riverdale (TV 2017), bughead - Fandom)
9. Be Lonely With Me by bughead_is_riverdale (Riverdale (TV 2017))
10. Murder, He Wrote by bluevelvetvideo, psychobetts (Riverdale (TV 2017))
11. it's found us like i have found you by OpportunisticHag (Riverdale (TV 2017))
12. cake and cardigans by heytherejones (Riverdale (TV 2017), bughead - Fandom, more)
13. Snakes and Crowns by PopsAfterDark (Riverdale (TV 2017))
14. Fight or Flight by CrashHale (Riverdale (TV 2017))
15. (my youth ain't) tangled up in bad decisions by singsongsung (Riverdale (TV 2017))
16. Definition of Want by FrostedGemstones22 (Riverdale (TV 2017))
17. Drive by AdamantEve (Riverdale (TV 2017))
18. Double-Booked by IndianSummer13 (Riverdale (TV 2017))
19. Speed & Serendipity by PeaceBlessingsPeyton (Riverdale (TV 2017), Archie Comics, more)
20. The Boy on the Bike by SereneCalamity (Riverdale (TV 2017), Archie Comics, more)