Fics like Mothman x Reader

You never thought it'd happen but it did you hooked up with the local legend himself only to never see each other again until one afternoon after an accident where he comes to your rescue?

You may also like

  1. Goodnight by chiicsilla (Original Work, Mothman (Folklore))
  2. Day 1 - Cryptid Hunt by InfiniTeaElk (Lemon Demon (Musician), Original Work, more)
  3. mothman is real and he wants to kill me by wesslan (Batman - All Media Types, Mothman (Folklore))
  4. Light Trap by CUMMANDER%20OSHA (Mothman (Folklore))
  5. Feathers & Fidelity by finchieclown (Mothman (Folklore))
  6. Softer Than the Summer Night by GoblinofLichens (Mothman (Folklore))
  7. i, ebony dark'ness dementia raven way, become The Most Goffic :) by orphan_account (Mothman (Folklore))
  8. A Very Cryptic Cryptid Prophecy by Yaoi_is_better_than_life (Mothman (Folklore), Jersey Devil (Folklore))
  9. Lustful Lepidoptera by SCP_1471 (Original Work, Mothman (Folklore))
  10. A Quiet Night in West Virginia by Greater_Axelord (Mothman (Folklore))
  11. Liminal Time by EnemyArtichoke (呪術廻戦 | Jujutsu Kaisen (Manga), 呪術廻戦 | Jujutsu Kaisen (Anime), more)
  12. Visiting Town by ScalesForever (Good Omens (TV), Good Omens - Neil Gaiman & Terry Pratchett, more)
  13. My.... Mothman?!?!?!1!?1 by pastaflavouredjuulpod (Mothman (Folklore))
  14. The Nice and Accurate Mothman Prophecies by Tired_Lazarus, scullyphile (Good Omens - All Media Types, Good Omens (TV), more)
  15. Mothman for U.S. Senate: An Indescribable Horror You Can Trust by eddiebloom3 (Political RPF - US 21st c., Mothman (Folklore))
  16. Sucks to be Pleasant with You by orphan_account (American Horror Story: Apocalypse, American Horror Story, more)
  17. There is a Light by MothmanIzReal (Mothman (Folklore), Buzzfeed Unsolved (Web Series))
  18. Starry Night (Mothman/Reader) by riveraugust (Mothman (Folklore))
  19. a mothman fic i guess by arbutusunedo (Mothman (Folklore))
  20. you come in here, you drink my coffee (Mothman (Folklore), Original Work)