Fics like Inconvenient Mistletoe

Ichabbie, in which secondary characters are NOT handled idiotically. After a Mistletoe Incident, Ichabod decides he's done ignoring the elephant in the room and confronts Abbie about their relationship head on. This story spans the whole Apocalypse.

You may also like

1. Blue Jeans and Thai Food by ladygray99 (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
2. Seventeen times Bad Wolf Interfered by Eshnoazot (Doctor Who, Doctor Who (2005), more)
3. In Orbit by sneetchstar (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
4. Everything Old Is New Again by samyazaz (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
5. Such a Thing of Wonder in the Crowd by The_Unnatural_Disaster (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
6. a more perfect Union by scifisis (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
7. Miss A.Mills - Librarian by HappyHappyReader (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
8. Darcy Lewis vs. the Multi-Verse by aForgottenWeasley (The Avengers (Marvel Movies), Thor (Movies), more)
9. [vid] Stand By You by thingswithwings (Alphas (TV), Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV), more)
10. A Gentleman's Dare by MissMaudlin (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
11. Nine Months by CastleriggCircle (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
12. Creature Comforts by theheadandthekin (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
13. Ischium by YoursHopefully (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
14. Hide Away by likebunnies (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
15. You Always Want What You're Running From by fairytalesandfolklore (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
16. She and He by CreepingMuse (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
17. You Can't Go Home Again by Largishcat (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
18. The Timepiece by boodacket (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
19. Through These Centuries by MyLifeMyLove7 (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
20. Brighter Than the Sun by killabeez (Lost Girl, Merlin (TV), more)