Fics like Another Chance, For Real This Time

What You Need To Know Commences when Peyton goes to Lucas’ house a few days after Dan Scott’s basketball party and everything is canon to then, except that nobody knows Brooke and Lucas have already had a date and Nathan and Haley aren’t dating at all. This is what happens when you think ... what if, when Peyton sees Brooke in Lucas' bedroom in S1, Ep 9, and she says "I made a mistake," she realises that she did indeed make a mistake, but walking away from Lucas at the basketball party wasn't it.

You may also like

  1. Never Let Me Go by stellugh (One Tree Hill)
  2. Drabbles From Before by rositamia (Popslash, X-Men (Movieverse), more)
  3. I Wish You Could Know Me by orphan_account (One Tree Hill)
  4. Marshall Of His Heart by StillFeelLikeATeenager (One Tree Hill)
  5. just like honey by alciavikkander (One Tree Hill)
  6. One Shot Requests (Currently Open) by aft33 (Glee, 13 Reasons Why (TV), more)
  7. Blood is Thick, But Love is Thicker by melissaheather (Outer Banks (TV), One Tree Hill)
  8. may i feel, said he by sugargroupie (One Tree Hill)
  9. Consider Me by KayKel108 (Arrow (TV 2012), One Tree Hill)
  10. Conversations by graceverse (One Tree Hill)
  11. hate is safer than love by goldclock (One Tree Hill)
  12. I need you... more than ever. by Ayooheather (One Tree Hill)
  13. something that'll haunt me when you're not around by secretsarenotforfree (One Tree Hill)
  14. Every Rose Has Its Thorn by Curly_One (One Tree Hill)
  15. No One Else Will Do by StillFeelLikeATeenager (One Tree Hill)
  16. How To Play And Win by graceverse (One Tree Hill)
  17. Turquoise by StillFeelLikeATeenager (One Tree Hill)
  18. An Extremely Short-Lived Plan C by StillFeelLikeATeenager (One Tree Hill)
  19. Feel Like Yours by nerdy_writer_65 (One Tree Hill)
  20. Unconditionally by anewkindofme (One Tree Hill)