Fics like Never Let Me Go

Lucas thought he and Peyton were destined to be together. But what if he made a mistake picking the curly-haired blonde over the cheery brunette? [a rewritten version of events in one tree hill, based loosely around seasons 1-3]

You may also like

  1. One Shot Requests (Currently Open) by aft33 (Glee, 13 Reasons Why (TV), more)
  2. I'd Love It If We Made It by stellugh (One Tree Hill)
  3. Love Island - Fandoms Edition by twobushplain (Outer Banks (TV), Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV), more)
  4. Blood is Thick, But Love is Thicker by melissaheather (Outer Banks (TV), One Tree Hill)
  5. Big, Big Mistake by skittlebox (One Tree Hill)
  6. An Extremely Short-Lived Plan C by StillFeelLikeATeenager (One Tree Hill)
  7. Did you ever miss me? by Ayooheather (One Tree Hill)
  8. Unconditionally by anewkindofme (One Tree Hill)
  9. Feel Like Yours by nerdy_writer_65 (One Tree Hill)
  10. Consider Me by KayKel108 (Arrow (TV 2012), One Tree Hill)
  11. Twenty Three by graceverse (One Tree Hill)
  12. I Don't Wanna Be by LovinTheHarmony (The Wilds (TV 2020), One Tree Hill)
  13. mosaic broken hearts by getcozywithtposey (One Tree Hill)
  14. love until it hurts by katiekinswrites (Gossip Girl, One Tree Hill)
  15. Sure by bluelilyrose (One Tree Hill)
  16. I Wish You Could Know Me by orphan_account (One Tree Hill)
  17. Let Me Help You With Your Baggage by StillFeelLikeATeenager (One Tree Hill)
  18. Every Choice You Make by StillFeelLikeATeenager (One Tree Hill)
  19. Every Rose Has Its Thorn by Curly_One (One Tree Hill)
  20. The Wreck of Our Hearts by katiekinswrites (One Tree Hill, Gossip Girl)