Fics like Second First Times

Andy goes looking for his father to try to salvage a broken relationship, and walks away with something completely different when he meets a familiar face from his past. While he tries to mend one part of his life, something new begins to grow and blossom. Andy just hopes he can hold on to this new secret before it breaks, too.

You may also like

1. Janitor's Room by Kelly_jo (Toy Story (Movies))
2. Sheriff Around These Parts by RandomWriter71 (Toy Story (Movies))
3. forever we'll be (you and me) by cherryvanilla (Toy Story (Movies))
4. From The Stars To Those We Left On Earth by MintyTrifecta (Toy Story (Movies))
5. There's a whole lot I want to say by belleevangeline (Toy Story (Movies))
6. June Trans Headcanons by DarkestKnight91 (Mother 2: Gyiyg no Gyakushuu | EarthBound, Gravity Falls, more)
7. Space Donuts & Cowboy Coffee by upwards_descent (Toy Story (Movies), Buzz Lightyear of Star Command (Cartoon))
8. Futa on male Prompts by Friskriel15 (Original Work, Multi-Fandom, more)
9. Jessie Rose and The Seven Toys by Broppy2314, infinitely_buzzie (Toy Story (Movies))
10. Heaven can wait, we’re only watching the skies by sanopan (Toy Story (Movies))
11. Beyond Infinity by Emerald_Sakura (Toy Story (Movies))
12. (Not) Forgotten Times by TenvalKazeg (Toy Story (Movies))
13. Falling With Not All That Much Style by nomsy (Toy Story (Movies))
14. if it's not love, then it's the bomb (that will bring us together) by crowcuth22 (Toy Story (Movies))
15. The reign of Morty by Geo_Soul (Rick and Morty, Teen Titans - All Media Types, more)
16. Generations of a Cowboy’s Heart (Toy Story (Movies))
17. Let Down by bottled_lightning (Toy Story (Movies))
18. Untitled by DKM01_Archivist (Toy Story (Movies))
19. Falling Off My Board (and Falling for You) by YodelingProspector (Toy Story (Movies))
20. Old Man by sanopan (Toy Story (Movies))