Fics like Matchmaker

Every year for Valentine's Day, Castiel's high school offers a matchmaking fundraiser service that tells each person which student they're most compatible with. Heterosexual results only, of course. Enter: Charlie Bradbury with a brilliant idea to switch names on their Matchmaker quiz so that they'll both get the result they want. Nothing could possibly go wrong.

You may also like

1. My New York Valentine by followyourenergy (Supernatural)
2. Hush Thee, My Darling by hazelNuts (Supernatural)
3. About You by LetThereBeDestiel (Supernatural)
4. A Special Something by whelvenwings (Supernatural)
5. The Honey Bee Theories by queentangerine (Supernatural)
6. A Clever Suggestion by Annie%20D (Supernatural)
7. The Extraordinarily Disappointing Fragrance of Cheese by SillyBlue (Supernatural)
8. Nobody's Fault But Mine by peanutbutterjelly-pie (Supernatural)
9. There Must Also Be a Lock by whelvenwings (Supernatural)
10. Better Latte Than Never by whelvenwings (Supernatural)
11. Obvious by Jacqueline%20Albright-Beckett (Supernatural)
12. Class Couple by followyourenergy (Supernatural)
13. Valentine's Day by destieldrabblesdaily (Supernatural)
14. Kiss for a Kiss by FagurFiskur (Supernatural)
15. coup de foudre by microcomets (Supernatural)
16. homeward bound by microcomets (Supernatural)
17. Not On The Menu by Efflorescent (Supernatural)
18. Of Evil Friends and Party Games by ratherbehere (Supernatural)
19. Morning Sunshine by galaxystiel (Supernatural)
20. From The Outside by peanutbutterjelly-pie (Supernatural)