Fics like Wish you didn't

Josie knew how to play this game, she'd played it since the two broke up. Penelope would act out and Josie would react, at the end of the day she would spin reason onto why Penelope acted this way and decided retaliation was not the answer. However Penelope knew what no one else knew how to do she knew how to push all of the level headed Josie Saltzman's buttons.

You may also like

1. My Magic, Your Medicine by NotteLunae (The Originals (TV))
2. You’ve got every right to leave (but stay with me) by Bluejay720 (Legacies (TV 2018))
3. the truth is (i still love you) by sapphicshaw (Legacies (TV 2018))
4. Wolf Woes by btvscharmedgirl (Legacies (TV 2018), The Originals (TV))
5. One Day You'll Understand (When You Love Someone) by josie_josette (Legacies (TV 2018), The Originals (TV))
6. She's QB 1, I'm Head Cheer by allweseeislight (Legacies (TV 2018))
7. it's a date (the only problem is it's fake) by avengerskye (Legacies (TV 2018))
8. A Sleepless Night by Penelovemepark (Legacies (TV 2018))
9. This madness in my soul by Knight_of_darkness (Legacies (TV 2018))
10. You Won't Ever Be Lonely by FallingArtist (Legacies (TV 2018))
11. Coffee on Monday, Flowers on Friday by Redezzy (Legacies (TV 2018))
12. Take a Trip into My Garden by chrysanthemum_red (Legacies (TV 2018))
13. Heaven is not fit to house a love (like you and I) by pr3ttygirlav (Legacies (TV 2018), The Originals (TV))
14. The Mikaelson girls by GNM_dreaming_girl (The Originals (TV), The Vampire Diaries (TV), more)
15. Heard by smileslikesunset (Legacies (TV 2018))
16. can we kiss forever? by voidpen (Legacies (TV 2018), The Vampire Diaries (TV), more)
17. get you the moon by voidpen (Legacies (TV 2018), The Vampire Diaries (TV), more)
18. oh no (here we go again) by sapphicshaw (Legacies (TV 2018))
19. didn't mean to get so close (and i know that i should probably go) by kelleybrohara5 (Legacies (TV 2018))
20. What should've happened by idontknow108 (Legacies (TV 2018), The Originals (TV), more)