Fics like A Sleepless Night

Penelope hates how much she wants to fall into Josie’s arms. How much she still loves her, after all she’s put her through. Josie can talk all she wants about how Penelope broke her heart, as if Josie didn’t break hers every single time she left her for Lizzie, every time Penelope spent waiting up for a date that never happened because Josie was too busy being too selfless. Every time Josie put everyone but Penelope before herself. Penelope has a sleepless night, and wanders the school before overhearing a particularly damaging conversation.

You may also like

  1. let's pretend (you're mine) by saltzpen (Legacies (TV 2018))
  2. try to be civil by that_one_urchin (Legacies (TV 2018))
  3. can you blame me for wanting a little bit more? by avengerskye (Legacies (TV 2018))
  4. The Trilateral Tournament by Marz_Attag (Legacies (TV 2018))
  5. they took the midnight train (goin’ anywhere) by that_one_urchin (Legacies (TV 2018), Glee)
  6. You're my muse - the force that guides my pen by TravelerByNature (Legacies (TV 2018))
  7. Metanoia by Haylee_BB (The Vampire Diaries & Related Fandoms, The Vampire Diaries (TV), more)
  8. moonlight on broken hearts and burning regrets by mintwhiskey (Legacies (TV 2018))
  9. A Perfect Plan by Tamoline (Legacies (TV 2018))
  10. (meet me) under the mistletoe by saltzpen (Legacies (TV 2018))
  11. One Last Chance by MakerofTales (The Originals (TV), Legacies (TV 2018), more)
  12. kintsukuroi by mangosashimi (Legacies (TV 2018))
  13. What Could Have Been by TNaPKI (The Originals (TV), The Vampire Diaries & Related Fandoms, more)
  14. you make me catch my breath (it's you, it's always been you) by cortanasol (Legacies (TV 2018))
  15. it's hard to breathe (when you're in the air) by ToriWritesStories (Legacies (TV 2018))
  16. What should've happened by idontknow108 (Legacies (TV 2018), The Originals (TV), more)
  17. Futures Past by WhiteWolf14 (The Vampire Diaries (TV), The Vampire Diaries & Related Fandoms, more)
  18. snapping one, two, where are you? (you're still in my heart) by exileee (Legacies (TV 2018))
  19. it's a date (the only problem is it's fake) by avengerskye (Legacies (TV 2018))
  20. (Give Me A Chance To) Prove It To You by penelopeparkman (Legacies (TV 2018))