Fics like Caught Off Guard

As it turns out, people are much different when caught off guard. A fact that HABIT learns the hard way still applies to himself, regardless of how in control of his situation he thinks he is.

You may also like

  1. The Troubles We Face by moflight (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets, more)
  2. nasty habits by horseshoeoverlook (Everyman HYBRID)
  3. Not Evan by DEADAMSEL (Everyman HYBRID, Creepypasta - Fandom)
  4. EveryTribeHornets0 by HamiltonMarbleHornetsTWD (Everyman HYBRID, Tribe Twelve, more)
  5. I know you’ll get what you deserve. by dogwaterfunctioning (Everyman HYBRID)
  6. get down, make love by thefuckingpumpkins (Everyman HYBRID)
  7. picking off the petals; i'll let you if you're gentle by gaygoyle (Everyman HYBRID, Slenderverse - Fandom)
  8. It’s not Evan. by CicadaDays (Everyman HYBRID)
  9. Nothing Comes as Easy as You by orphan_account (Everyman HYBRID)
  10. Drinking Habit by orphan_account (Everyman HYBRID, Tribe Twelve)
  11. Demonoid Phenomenon by orphan_account (Everyman HYBRID, Tribe Twelve)
  12. Creepypasta x Reader boyfriend scenarios by Stonemedusa (Creepypasta - Fandom, Tribe Twelve)
  13. Lie Awake (Thinking of Everything You've Been Through) by mainstayastro (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets, more)
  14. dark necessities (are part of my design) by thefuckingpumpkins (Everyman HYBRID)
  15. :D by orphan_account (Everyman HYBRID)
  16. I want to die with all my scars (If they don't like they way we are, then fuck them) by Jay_is_sleeping (Creepypasta - Fandom, Slender Man Mythos, more)
  17. western nights by aloha2843 (Everyman HYBRID)
  18. Its Warmer in the Basement by somefinalgirl (Everyman HYBRID)
  19. BESTIA CONCEPTVS OVIVM by PomegranatePomsom (Everyman HYBRID, Tribe Twelve)
  20. July 13th, Iowa by saturnsfather (MLAndersen0, Everyman HYBRID, more)