Fics like get down, make love

You had found Evan through an online listing for a room with reasonably decent rent, as long as you cover your portion of utilities. It is in a safe, quiet area, and Evan seemed like a really nice guy based on the texts you two sent back and forth. But what you did not expect was for him to be so attractive, or to be so capricious.

You may also like

1. A ReRun Gone Bad by Gay_Artist_Tim_Wright (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Creepypasta - Fandom, more)
2. Marble Hybrids by WriterWriterHeadonFire (Everyman HYBRID, Marble Hornets, more)
3. “I’ve got my Eye on you.” A Tribetwelve(+EverymanHYBRID) x Male Reader Fanfic by DeviHollow (Tribe Twelve, Everyman HYBRID, more)
4. eat it like it's gonna get away by thefuckingpumpkins (Everyman HYBRID)
5. Indulgence by totallynoteli (Everyman HYBRID)
6. the key to the lock in your house by averageoceanidenjoyer (Everyman HYBRID)
7. dark necessities (are part of my design) by thefuckingpumpkins (Everyman HYBRID)
8. Parasocial by livelaughluv69 (Everyman HYBRID)
9. Anesthesia by Brain_Soup_Brian (Marble Hornets, Everyman HYBRID, more)
10. nasty habits by horseshoeoverlook (Everyman HYBRID)
11. It’s not Evan. by CicadaDays (Everyman HYBRID)
12. What Hides in Shadows - A Worm Creepypasta by Beastrider9 (Parahumans Series - Wildbow, Creepypasta - Fandom, more)
13. :D by orphan_account (Everyman HYBRID)
14. Near Life Experience by briqhtvenus (Everyman HYBRID)
15. Habit x Reader: Beg for It by datauthorress (Everyman HYBRID)
16. it doesn’t take much to cover up small cuts by zombifiedcowboy (Everyman HYBRID)
17. Too Tough To Die by BoyOneder (Everyman HYBRID, Slender Man Mythos)
18. sit, stay, beg by firstchristmas (Creepypasta - Fandom, Everyman HYBRID)
19. Tangled with You by b_mrssnow (Everyman HYBRID)
20. Can You Taste It? by pervpasta (Creepypasta - Fandom, Everyman HYBRID, more)