Fics like The Curious Case of that Time with the Thing

Shawn kind of wanted to ask for a cookie, but he didn't think he'd like the taste of arsenic.

You may also like

1. i solemnly swear (that i am up to no good) by jumpfall (Suits (TV), Psych, more)
2. Spencers by Vennat (Criminal Minds (US TV), Psych)
3. The Clear and Present Danger of Regarding Henry by Teragram (Psych)
4. Varying Degrees of Con-artistry by LuciaZephyr (Psych)
5. Single-O by janewestin (Psych)
6. Drabbles Written for Porn Battle XV by Missy (Psych, Oglaf, more)
7. you laughed and you complained, but you didn't drown by Princex_N (Psych)
8. Shawn and Lassie Do a Good, Good Thing by xDinahQueenx (Psych)
9. I've Heard It Both Ways by GoldStarGrl (Psych)
10. Six Degrees of Speculation by sebviathan (Psych)
11. Shot Through the Heart (And You're to Blame) by trixietru (Psych)
12. Time Is An Illusion, Time Travel Doubly So by DinerGuy (Psych, Quantum Leap)
13. The Walrus and the Guy Who Carpents by plainapple (Psych)
14. The Closet and Dr. Caligari by Loz (Psych)
15. ID by SuperVengerDead_615 (Psych, Criminal Minds)
16. A Tin Man Reprised by Zaxal (Psych)
17. There's Something About Jane by AvocadoLove (Psych, The Mentalist)
18. Killing Me Slowly by EclipseWing (Psych)
19. Confidentiality by sebviathan (Psych)
20. Gus Has a Bad Feeling About This (Totally Like Han Solo, Only Hotter) by apple_pi (Psych)