Fics like The Closet and Dr. Caligari

When Shawn and Gus investigate the death of a stage manager they find themselves dragged into a world of British accents and hypnotism. In order to work toward solving the case, Shawn lets himself get hypnotized on stage and proceeds to get handsy. And then bad things happen, rocks fall, everyone doesn’t-quite-die, but Gus is not happy, because his friendship with Shawn reaches tipping point.

You may also like

1. The Head, The Heart, The Whole Damn... Thing by sebviathan (Psych)
2. And They Say Romance is Dead by pointyshades (Psych)
3. Shawn and Lassie Do a Good, Good Thing by xDinahQueenx (Psych)
4. The Walrus and the Guy Who Carpents by plainapple (Psych)
5. Single-O by janewestin (Psych)
6. Drabbles Written for Porn Battle XV by Missy (Psych, Oglaf, more)
7. The Hours That Are Passed by elles_letters (Psych)
8. 9:15 to Lompoc by sebviathan (Psych)
9. Varying Degrees of Con-artistry by LuciaZephyr (Psych)
10. Psychics, Agents, and Terrorists, Oh My! by PapayaK (Psych)
11. Shawn Spencer: The Ultimate Reference by sottovoce81 (Psych, Supernatural)
12. Dyslexic Heart by trixietru (Psych)
13. Spencers by Vennat (Criminal Minds (US TV), Psych)
14. Fanmixes and Playlists (The Avengers (Marvel Movies), Supernatural, more)
15. Losing My Mind by janewestin (Psych)
16. Want a drink? by feriowind (Psych)
17. Safe by Zaxal (Psych)
18. Space by cosette141 (Psych)
19. Guy Love: Bromance and the Bridge Between Homophobia and Homoeroticism by orphan_account (Psych, Supernatural, more)
20. What's Gus Got To Do With It? by purewanderlust (Psych)