Fics like Firewalk

Shawn gets his hands on Eleanor, Chidi, Tahani, and Jason and tries to prove they're selfish by making them turn down their greatest dreams and deepest fantasies. It's foolproof, he thinks. Except Jason Mendoza is a bigger fool than anyone, even an almighty immortal being, could have ever planned for.

You may also like

1. Introduction to Infernal Crossover by Rockinlibrarian (Community (TV), The Good Place (TV))
2. We'll always find each other by LisaBonn22 (Project Hail Mary (2026), Project Hail Mary - Andy Weir, more)
3. Occupational Hazards by mylittleredgirl (The Good Place (TV))
4. Enough by grumpyhedgehogs (The Good Place (TV))
5. Operation: Seduce Michael by blithers (The Good Place (TV))
6. Hell Takes All the Credit by burglebezzlement (The Good Place (TV))
7. The Bed by SophCat (The Good Place (TV))
8. Care and Feeding of Your Janet by samalander (The Good Place (TV))
9. Welcome, Light Yagami by uninterestedasphalt (Death Note (Anime & Manga), The Good Place (TV))
10. Fate, Feelings, and Other Forked-Up Nonsense by fairytalesandfolklore (The Good Place (TV))
11. Life, Death, and Breakfast by LovelyPoet (The Good Place (TV))
12. The Dowry of Shellfish by worldturtling (The Good Place (TV))
13. lying side by side by pickledragon (The Good Place (TV))
14. Mambo No. 218 by zedpm (The Good Place (TV))
15. Clues on How to Stay by zedpm (The Good Place (TV))
16. What Sarah Said [Fanvid] by periru3 (11.22.63 (TV), Arrival (2016), more)
17. Gator-Proof Fence by burglebezzlement (The Good Place (TV))
18. You Could Be the King, but Watch the Queen Conquer by phoenixyfriend (The Good Place (TV))
19. Choose Your Own Torture by antivillain (The Good Place (TV))
20. other people by counterheist (The Good Place (TV), Parks and Recreation)