Fics like Choose Your Own Torture

Michael's neighborhood keeps failing. Time to see if the woman who keeps messing everything up might have the answer to how to fix it.

You may also like

1. Seal the Deal by grumpyhedgehogs (The Good Place (TV))
2. Let Me Look at the Sun by Telanu (The Good Place (TV))
3. Enough by grumpyhedgehogs (The Good Place (TV))
4. [vid] Afterlife by thingswithwings (The Good Place (TV))
5. Chidi's Five-Day Crash Course in Being Halfway Decent by susieboo (The Good Place (TV))
6. Five Subfolders of Existence by storiesfortravellers (The Good Place (TV))
7. A Statistical Error in a Dog-Friendly Neighborhood; Or: All Dogs Go To The Good Place by luftnarp-writing (Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV), The Good Place (TV))
8. Free Netflix Subscription by Wildgoosery (The Good Place (TV))
9. the guard place by thirtysixhudson (The Old Guard (Movie 2020), The Good Place (TV))
10. A Warm, Sexy Trumpet Mute by edna_blackadder (The Good Place (TV))
11. Operation: Seduce Michael by blithers (The Good Place (TV))
12. The Good Farewell by Username12345678 (The Good Place (TV))
13. Give Me This, at Least by telm_393 (The Good Place (TV))
14. Temptations of Infuriation by bYeFeliciaah (The Good Place (TV))
15. the pleasure principle by yasaman (The Good Place (TV))
16. What We Are to Each Other by karahboou (The Good Place (TV))
17. Well-Forked by Poetry (The Good Place (TV))
18. What Sarah Said [Fanvid] by periru3 (11.22.63 (TV), Arrival (2016), more)
19. Five Times Philosophy Class Was Totally Easy by storiesfortravellers (The Good Place (TV))
20. Occupational Hazards by mylittleredgirl (The Good Place (TV))