Fics like there’ll be much mistletoeing and hearts will be glowing

She has to have been sent to him by the universe to test his patience—a Christmas specter the likes of which Ebenezer Scrooge would scoff at. Rebecca Bunch crashes into Nathaniel's life with a stupid, wild plan and an unparalleled lack of self-preservation. What else is he supposed to do but help her? 'Tis the season for shenanigans.

You may also like

Bite-Size Love by heartbash (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
Lotus by skyling (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
Where the lovelight gleams by middlemarch (Poldark (TV 2015), Star Wars: The Last Jedi (2017), more)
ten steps ahead (don't leave me behind) by FeoplePeel (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
It's the Little Things by sporklift (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
Supply Shopping and Tree Climbing by justwantedtodance (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
Meant To Be Exemption by roadtripwithlucifer (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
play the game by putting on the brakes by itsactuallycorrine (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
Panem with Parents: The Question by TabbyCatLibrarian (Hunger Games Series - All Media Types, Hunger Games Trilogy - Suzanne Collins, more)
the breaths you take by commatothetop (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
If this place is supposed to be so good, then where is Josh? by threadofgrace (The Good Place (TV), Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
Josh and I Are Secret Internet Dating! by Diaphenia (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
Savasana by sporklift (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
Blame It On The Alcohol by yumytaffy (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV), Parks and Recreation)
Why Is Josh's Friend's Uncle Talking to Me About Vampires? by etothepii (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
A Dream For Right Now by DCBrierton (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
this mess was yours now your mess is mine by notbang (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
don't know what i've done (or if i like what i've begun) by notbang (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
settled like a loaded weapon by notbang (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
all the solutions were trial and error by akisazame (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))