Fics like Open Your Heart to Temptation

Youth Pastor Craig Tucker finds an unconscious demon in the snow one night. Normal priests would have done anything else that WASN'T what Craig did once the demon woke up.

You may also like

1. The Bucket List by RoseyR (South Park)
2. Gold Digger by indirectkissesiniceland (South Park)
3. The Roommate by theyregonnagetme (South Park)
4. There's My Boy by fancypearl (South Park)
5. Mysterion Begins by indirectkissesiniceland (South Park)
6. dirt wizard by orphan_account (South Park)
7. In the Dusk of Stars by Courtanie (South Park, South Park: The Stick of Truth (Video Game))
8. Leave the Pieces by hollycomb (South Park)
9. Pas de Deux by livviartt (South Park)
10. Hot for Teacher by craigorytucker (South Park)
11. might last a day (minus forever) by cherryvanilla (South Park)
12. Interlude by PBJellie (South Park)
13. Mostly You Just Make Me Mad by WardsbackPoet (South Park)
14. no-one saw me (not in the way you did) by kiritila (South Park)
15. No Show Kids by hypercatt (South Park)
16. Style One-Shot Requests ❤️ by Meepleep (South Park)
17. Ladies and Gentlemen We Are Floating in Space by gremlinteeth (South Park)
18. fake it 'till you make it by mewtwos (South Park)
19. The Difference of Day and Night by Katakombae (South Park)
20. The Gods Watched Over Us by UrsaMajorStories (South Park)