Fics like The Great Vanishing Act of 1994

1994: Marshall Teller vanishes the same night the Old Hitchcock Mill burns down. 2004: Marshall Teller returns the same night the Old Hitchcock Mill burned down ten years ago. Which would have been great, if not for one tiny, little, itty bitty issue. He hasn't aged a day.

You may also like

1. Into the Heart of the Lost by lucindarobinsonvevo (Eerie Indiana)
2. Strength in Your Soil by flashforeward (Eerie Indiana)
3. Be the Bird, Be the Key by lucindarobinsonvevo (Eerie Indiana, Eerie Indiana: The Other Dimension)
4. Not a Paper Girl by flashforeward (Eerie Indiana)
5. And the Night Was Still Young by lucindarobinsonvevo (Eerie Indiana)
6. A Tale of Two Eeries by lucindarobinsonvevo (Eerie Indiana, Eerie Indiana: The Other Dimension)
7. The Lonely Ghost by flashforeward (Eerie Indiana)
8. What Remains of Marshall Teller by lucindarobinsonvevo (Eerie Indiana, Hocus Pocus (1993))
9. A Proposition (That Janet Donner Doesn't Totally Hate) by lucindarobinsonvevo (Eerie Indiana)
10. The Strangest New Year by ftrbestseller (Eerie Indiana)
11. The Obligatory Coffee Shop AU (Because Every Fandom Has One) by flashforeward (Eerie Indiana)
12. After the Credits Roll by lucindarobinsonvevo (Eerie Indiana)
13. We're Not Friends (Eerie Indiana)
14. Mega-Voodoo-Eerie-Weirdness by flashforeward (Eerie Indiana)
15. Sleeping Dogs by chiiyo86 (Eerie Indiana)
16. Lie Back and Think of Mars by Deifire (Eerie Indiana)
17. One Tenth of a Century by lucindarobinsonvevo (Eerie Indiana)
18. Touch-Tone Telephone by psychodive (Eerie Indiana)
19. An Eerie Little Christmas by ftrbestseller (Eerie Indiana)
20. As Safe as Houses by lucindarobinsonvevo (Eerie Indiana)