Fics like The Story of Us

"Wait, do you know what this means, Castiel? It means that you're Taylor Swift." Castiel blinks. "What?" he asks. And he purposely does not mention the fact that Dean's first impression was of him singing Taylor Swift. "In the song 'You Belong With Me'." In which Castiel is the shy and socially awkward nerd going into junior year, Charlie is his energetic best friend who is basically the entire fandom, Kevin is a super nerd, and Garth is just Garth. Oh, and Dean is the new one who only just moved into the house behind Castiel's and walked in on him (badly) belting out Taylor Swift while mowing the lawn.

You may also like

1. Of Flowers and Flours by lemonsorbae (Supernatural)
2. Truth or Dare? by quillquiver (Supernatural)
3. In This Secluded Spot I Respond As I Wouldn't Dare Elsewhere by RhymePhile (Supernatural)
4. The Honey Bee Theories by queentangerine (Supernatural)
5. Prosopagnosia by misseditallagain (Supernatural)
6. Serendipity by whelvenwings (Supernatural)
7. flour in your hair by cassiewrites (Supernatural)
8. Alright by turningthepages (Supernatural)
9. Seeking Friendship by mnwood (Supernatural)
10. Inevitably Homoerotic Holiday Hits by prosopopeya (Supernatural)
11. We Are Forever Young (At Heart) by WanderingWordNerd (Supernatural)
12. Bouquet by everydayistuesday (Supernatural)
13. Rumor Has It by GatesKeeper (Supernatural)
14. Tomorrow's Dream by peanutbutterjelly-pie (Supernatural)
15. Plus One by BlueMasquerade (Supernatural)
16. If Angels Were Men by manifestingwings (Supernatural)
17. The Emptiness of His Chest by of_dreamdust (Supernatural)
18. into the light by stydiaxdestiel (Supernatural)
19. All The Right Moves by Carver%20Edlund (Supernatural)
20. The Joy is in the Process by RhymePhile (Supernatural)