Fics like How could I ever forget? It's the first time

"Oh, hi!" Maddie looks surprised when she opens the door. "What are you doing here?" "I, uh." Buck hesitates. "I think Eddie just broke up with me?" Maddie's jaw drops. "You and Eddie were dating?" "Apparently," Buck replies, baffled. ~ Or, Buck isn't aware that he and Eddie were dating, thankfully Maddie is there to make sure he doesn't fumble the bag

You may also like

  1. The Elephant in the Room Never Forgets by exvichan (9-1-1 (TV))
  2. stupid reckless by buckleysapron (9-1-1 (TV))
  3. You can build a house, but not a home by justhockey (9-1-1 (TV))
  4. Ace of Hearts by glorious_spoon (9-1-1 (TV))
  5. everything you see (ain’t always what it seems) by autumnchills (9-1-1 (TV))
  6. The Bait and Switch by izquierd (9-1-1 (TV))
  7. Bonkers by Veronae (9-1-1 (TV))
  8. Got My Back by indecisivejoy (9-1-1 (TV))
  9. he’s the earth and heaven to you by justhockey (9-1-1 (TV))
  10. walking on a string by beetlesandstars (9-1-1 (TV))
  11. Ian Bradly Must Die, A Horror Movie Featuring Buck Buckley by shrimprangoon (9-1-1 (TV))
  12. lovefool by oneofthesirens (9-1-1 (TV))
  13. The Retreat. by Buddieaya (9-1-1 (TV))
  14. and suddenly, i’m holding the world in my arms by spideybegins (9-1-1 (TV))
  15. When The Past Comes Knocking by Iceprincess96 (9-1-1 (TV))
  16. and then they were groommates by elisela (9-1-1 (TV))
  17. you're a liar (my favorite liar) by donationwayne (9-1-1 (TV))
  18. intermeddle by paleredheadinascifi (9-1-1 (TV))
  19. So Empty, My Heart, My Soul by afternooncupoftea (9-1-1 (TV))
  20. Stick to Me, Ink on My Skin by ScentedBooks (9-1-1 (TV))