Fics like Reward

Matt swallowed hard, looking at you with wide, almost panicked eyes. “You’re not… you’re not really going to make me cry, are you?” You hummed softly and trailed your fingers over his chest like you had done earlier. “Maybe, maybe not. I guess it depends.” “Depends on what?” “On how good you sound without the tears,” you mused. In which you get to tie up Matt and tease him until he cries, just like Jay promised. (chapter one she/her pronouns, chapter two he/him pronouns)

You may also like

  1. I Wait to Be Led Into Temptation by eulimnion (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017))
  2. The Tape by labiamattjora (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017))
  3. ERP therapy for dummies by dummies by ingydar (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017))
  4. Expensive by stopmysinfulhand (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017))
  5. The Beantown by UncStillGotIt (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017))
  6. all i want (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017), Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie (2025), more)
  7. any way you choose me, it won't be wrong by JohnnySegment (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017))
  8. why tonight, why tonight? by onthecrescentofthehill (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017))
  9. wet hot canadian summer by Winsomenotions (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017))
  10. The Matt Johnson Girlfriend Experience by Wheat%20From%20Chaff (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017), Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie (2025))
  11. the b-friend (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017), Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie (2025))
  12. Jay McCarrol Explains How To Create A Film Score by apollojusticeforall (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017), Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie (2025))
  13. The Blindsided by owlthing00 (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017))
  14. Best Imitation of Myself by Wheat%20From%20Chaff (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017), Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie (2025))
  15. blue dawn by sulfuric (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017), Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie (2025))
  16. cinéma verité by falteringstar (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017), Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie (2025))
  17. The gentleman by barfdrinker (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017))
  18. i wish you'd talk, talk, wish you'd talk, talk, wish you'd talk, talk, wish you'd just talk to me by ingydar (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017))
  19. what the difference is (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017))
  20. foxes mate for life by caleheadism (Nirvanna the Band the Show (Canada TV 2017), Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie (2025))