Fics like With Arms Wide Open

Charlie, Vaggie, and Alastor are in a group dating polycule. Their world is turned on its head when Charlie finds out she's pregnant.

You may also like

1. Rising and Falling by lost_in_a_story (Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon))
2. Cleaning Up Your Mess by AkumaKami64 (Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon))
3. Together In My Pocket by keelywolfe (Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon))
4. Let's Be Alone Together by Chaos%20Gremlin (Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon), Hellaverse | Hazbin Hotel & Helluva Boss Universe)
5. Like the day I died by StardustMary (Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon))
6. The Day of My Knight by Chaos%20Gremlin (Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon))
7. Alastor and the Thoughtful, Sincere, Not Shitty, Very Kind Day by SuperLabel, wrdonerd (Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon))
8. Falling From Grace by YukimuraShuusukeGirl (InuYasha - A Feudal Fairy Tale, Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon))
9. R is for Revelator by BleakCinema (Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon))
10. Heavenly Reincarnation - An Abel Self-Insert. by Derpmaster9000 (Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon), Helluva Boss (Web Series))
11. Knife + Hart by BleakCinema (Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon))
12. Z is for Zero-Sum Game by eternalscout (Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon))
13. Shellshocked by VelkynKarma (Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon))
14. After Forever by TressidaDrake (Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon))
15. Beloved by OliveOil (Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon))
16. Y is for Yearning by pinfeatherss (Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon))
17. W is for Winning by flaggermousse (Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon))
18. G is for Gunpoint by ReminiscentBells (Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon))
19. Spider-Man: Web of Redemption by YourFriendlyNeighborSpiderMan (Spider-Man - All Media Types, Spider-Man (Comicverse), more)
20. Demon of the Airwaves by Redpandamaa (Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon))