Fics like Happily Ever After

Out of sympathy for the plight of Ruby and her friends, the Blacksmith offered to give them all a do-over, to recraft reality back to their first year at Beacon, a chance to do it all over again as ordinary students without all the mass murder and existential threats to civilization. But the Blacksmith, handling it with all her usual care and attentiveness, relied on the five of them to remember exactly how Beacon had been. Certainly, they had very clear memories of that time and no one would alter reality to make it fit their particular desires. These are heroes, they don't do things like that!

You may also like

1. For The Cause by Selene_Sokal (RWBY)
2. you've got me seeing stars by explosivesky (RWBY)
3. you're a mountain, full of glory by lescousinsdangereux (RWBY)
4. Forbidden Fruit by Selene_Sokal (RWBY)
5. The Wager by Lightbringer0 (RWBY)
6. Royal Treatment by Selene_Sokal (RWBY)
7. walk where the wild things grow by explosivesky (RWBY)
8. Here There Be Pirates by storylover543 (RWBY)
9. Sokal's Hypnovember Fics by Selene_Sokal (RWBY, The Legend of Zelda: The Ocarina of Time, more)
10. Spring Break At The Rose House by 6474131 (RWBY)
11. In the Pages of the Grimmoire by Selene_Sokal (RWBY)
12. Eight Idiots Save The Multiverse With Memes by Miodist (Persona 5, Cyberpunk 2077 (Video Game), more)
13. A Witch, A Queen, A Spartan, and their Goofball Lover by VANQUISHED653 (RWBY)
14. The Silver Light of Chaos by WitchQueenLeFay55 (RWBY)
15. A Semblance of Emotion by erisedfiction (RWBY)
16. Plans Go Awry by Selene_Sokal (RWBY)
17. The Heroic Age by Orichacos (RWBY)
18. Not-So-Noble Knight by Welp_there_we_go (Shovel Knight, RWBY)
19. She's Trying Her Best by Selene_Sokal (RWBY)
20. The Arc and the Overlord by linkjames24 (RWBY, オーバーロード - 丸山くがね | Overlord - Maruyama Kugane, more)