Fics like Promise I'll Be Gentle

From the first time you met, he's been nothing but a gentleman. A little odd, sure only coming around at night. The sweetest man you've had the pleasure of meeting, though you haven't met a lot. He's been winning you over every night until the point you let him in. And now he wants to show you what love feels like for the first time.

You may also like

1. For What Loves Us by Pixie2804 (Sinners (2025))
2. The Book of Miriam by weavingduck (Sinners (2025))
3. Ptolemaea by flixpi (Sinners (2025))
4. Ain't No Sunshine by mcgoverin (Sinners (2025))
5. The One He Lost by JinxxxTheWriter (Sinners (2025))
6. My mercy prevails over my wrath by soggy_soda (Sinners (2025))
7. It's time we go by metaphysicalhumanbeing (Sinners (2025))
8. Root Cellar by FoxTufts (Sinners (2025))
9. the places where we bled by jwangel (Sinners (2025))
10. Unholy by knewtoomuch (Sinners (2025))
11. Phantom Touch by FoxTufts (Sinners (2025))
12. Ripe for the Picking by jimmythecookiemonster (Sinners (2025))
13. Under your spell by technical_moose (Sinners (2025))
14. Your Monster by LostOnNeptune (Sinners (2025))
15. let's all raise a cup to pathetic vampires by pavlovianfuckery (Sinners (2025))
16. One Night in Chicago by ErinMorris (Sinners (2025), Interview with the Vampire (TV 2022))
17. Wild Mountain Thyme (Sinners (2025))
18. Take My Blood, Take My Pain by jimmythecookiemonster (Sinners (2025))
19. Paint Me Pretty by BleedingSunlight (Sinners (2025))
20. On a Mountain by sansomnus (Sinners (2025))