Fics like So you believe in God now?

Ilya and Shane’s first time fucking raw. • Or, a smutshot from the cottage.

You may also like

1. Every Bed is Cold Without Your Body by Waste_the_night (Heated Rivalry (TV))
2. Don’t Forget You Love Me by goldenlou (Heated Rivalry (TV))
3. The Whole List by FestiveFerret (Heated Rivalry (TV))
4. cottaging by gone_girl (Heated Rivalry (TV))
5. the season of peaches by EveFrancesca (Heated Rivalry (TV), Game Changers Series - Rachel Reid)
6. seeing stars by beautifullyblue (Heated Rivalry (TV))
7. eyes wide open, naked as we came by beautifulduckweed (Heated Rivalry (TV))
8. Kiss it better by DelululandQueen118 (Heated Rivalry (TV))
9. seahorses by yellobaby (Heated Rivalry (TV), Game Changers Series - Rachel Reid)
10. Can We Drag It Out & Never Quit? by Waste_the_night (Heated Rivalry (TV))
11. the beauty of payback by takupaku (Heated Rivalry (TV))
12. left turn on the way home by radialarch (Heated Rivalry (TV))
13. everybody makes mistakes by Space_Samurai (Heated Rivalry (TV), Game Changers Series - Rachel Reid)
14. crux by agathav (Heated Rivalry (TV))
15. no right to weep by ptrick65 (Heated Rivalry (TV), Game Changers | Heated Rivalry - All Media Types)
16. come real quick (and get inside my mind) by coffeeinallcaps (Heated Rivalry (TV))
17. the way to his heart by anincompletelist (Heated Rivalry (TV), Game Changers Series - Rachel Reid)
18. the first poem in the world (is I want to eat) by MemeKonHR (Heated Rivalry (TV), Game Changers Series - Rachel Reid)
19. hot tub fuck machine by yellobaby (Heated Rivalry (TV), Game Changers Series - Rachel Reid)
20. Cosmo’s “Situationship or Relationship?” Quiz by aislinnn (Heated Rivalry (TV))