Fics like Unexpected Surprise

What started out as an attempt to create a calm night for Puzzles, after he suffered through a rather rough pitch meeting, ends in a way neither of them could have ever imagined.

You may also like

1. The Brightest Stars by Lapis01 (SMG4 (Web Series))
2. Distracting Audience (SMG4 (Web Series), Calling All Villains - SMG4 (Web Series))
3. SMG4: Catch Me in the Pit by Krosshair (SMG4 (Web Series))
4. Angstober Gunshow Edition by Rosieflower27 (SMG4 (Web Series))
5. PunmasterLV16's Shatterverse Timeline: SMG4: Crystal Spletzer: Book 1: Remastered by Keyblade_Master_DJ102202 (SMG4 (Web Series), Super Mario & Related Fandoms, more)
6. Death Battle: Mr. Puzzles VS Vox (SMG4 VS Hazbin Hotel) by Keyblade_Master_DJ102202 (Death Battle (Web Series), SMG4 (Web Series), more)
7. Property Of Puzzlevision Inc by Lapis01, starteas (SMG4 (Web Series))
8. Drink 'Till Ya Drop by Lapis01, starteas (SMG4 (Web Series))
9. Leave Your Mark by Lapis01 (SMG4 (Web Series))
10. Jealous Sparks by That_One_Ambiguous_Anon (SMG4 (Web Series))
11. Love and Longing by Waterbatt (SMG4 (Web Series))
12. Total Drama: As Hosted by Genie! by n8han11 (Total Drama (Cartoon), Aladdin (Disney Animated Movies), more)
13. Broken Bottles And Heart-shaped Stickers by Lapis01 (SMG4 (Web Series))
14. Wildflower by BTAmono (SMG4 (Web Series))
15. A Little Helpful Push by side_rock (SMG4 (Web Series))
16. The One Night Stand by DeSsIe_ArtNFics (SMG4 (Web Series))
17. Times Collide by DehydratedStick (SMG4 (Web Series))
18. Eggdog's Other Dad by LunarPerri (SMG4 (Web Series), Super Mario & Related Fandoms)
19. The Showboat Sinker by Bonseyjones (SMG4 (Web Series))
20. Starlight, Starbright by Lapis01 (SMG4 (Web Series))