Fics like If Only You Liked Me Back

sequel to Watching The Moon in Desperate Hopes so if u havent read that i recommend you to read that first or else this may confuse you. This time Arthur sees this as an opportunity to get better with Rusty. Also side note, who is matt cuz like tb said arthur's married to matt ???😓 Reminder that this is my au with my headcanons and this is based of some facts tb said, also Rusty's wife broke up w/ him due to his anger issues and avoidant attachement

You may also like

You'll Stay (Even When I Hurt You) by Eclipseeks (The Moon I Rot Behind (Roblox))
I'm Here For You by thatoneskipy, tmirb (The Moon I Rot Behind (Roblox))
Before Christmas by DaddyPizzaGuy (The Moon I Rot Behind (Roblox))
The sunrise I flourish alongside by CAL1F0RN1A_R0LL (The Moon I Rot Behind (Roblox))
Look Up by overprivileged_youth (The Moon I Rot Behind (Roblox))
Let Me Descend by faefolkliterature (The Moon I Rot Behind (Roblox))
casual by percywercydercy (The Moon I Rot Behind (Roblox))
idk what to name this uhh devin jerks off by angelics_secretaccount4fics (The Moon I Rot Behind (Roblox))
I want to be... Normal? by vo1d_pers0n (The Moon I Rot Behind (Roblox))
(forever?????????) (The Moon I Rot Behind (Roblox))
Won’t you help me? by theeviltickler (The Moon I Rot Behind (Roblox))
Spiraling Into Misery by d1Kollektive (The Moon I Rot Behind (Roblox))
So Says the Writing on the Wall by y2queer (The Moon I Rot Behind (Roblox))
Helping Hand by d1Kollektive (The Moon I Rot Behind (Roblox))
REQUEST BOOK!!!! (REQ OPEN) by Heavn1ynol, NolsbyHeavn1y (Bad Things (Roblox), Let Him Go. (Roblox), more)
Multifandom Art Book~ ⋆｡°✩ by JoeSchmoeArt (Animal Hospital (Roblox), Bad Things (Roblox), more)
Please don't leave me, Rusty by plutonicdoom (The Moon I Rot Behind (Roblox))
Seven minutes of my guilt by ImGigi_IRL (The Moon I Rot Behind (Roblox))
mostly chimes (The Moon I Rot Behind (Roblox))
Special Decay 🧣🦌❤️‍🩹 by alligatorguppy (The Moon I Rot Behind (Roblox))